State Supreme Court Rules In Favor of Perdido Dunes Over Phoenix Rentals

OBA Staff • June 11, 2024

State Court used "Squatters' Rights" in awarding sliver of land


Perdido Dunes Lawsuit

Orange Beach, Ala. – (OBA) – Hidden between Phoenix East and Phoenix VIII is a slender building named Perdido Dunes. For many years Perdido Dunes has been using a two-and-a-half-foot strip of land owned by Phoenix Rentals. The long beachfront battle between Orange Beach condominiums has been settled, with the Alabama Supreme Court confirming a new tower is entitled to squatter's rights.


The Perdido Dunes condominium association in Orange Beach, Alabama, claimed squatting rights on a section of beachfront property. This case revolved around the principle of adverse possession, where the association maintained and used the property over an extended period without the owner's permission.


The case escalated through the legal system, eventually reaching the Alabama Supreme Court. The primary legal question was whether the condominium association's long-term use and improvement of the property constituted adverse possession under Alabama law.


The Alabama Supreme Court affirmed the condominium association's rights, upholding the lower court's decision. The ruling confirmed that the association had met the criteria for adverse possession, including continuous and exclusive use of the property for the statutory period.


Does Alabama have squatters' rights? According to Hemlane Property Management, In Alabama, for a squatter to make an adverse possession claim on a property, they must occupy the land continuously for 20 years. The possession must also be actual, open, notorious, exclusive, hostile, and under claim of right. This means the squatter must physically live on or make regular use of the property, in an obvious and public way, preventing the owner or others from using it themselves. The squatter's use should clearly indicate they are claiming ownership and not trying to hide their occupation.


If the squatter meets all the requirements of adverse possession for 20 years, they can gain legal title to the property, even without the original owner's permission. At that point, the squatter becomes the rightful owner in the eyes of Alabama law.


In this case, the Alabama Supreme Court upheld the judgment granting Perdido Dunes a prescriptive easement over the disputed property. This decision may have significant implications for property rights in Alabama, particularly concerning beachfront properties. It underscores the importance of property owners actively monitoring and maintaining their properties to prevent adverse possession claims.


Share this article w/ Friends...

Orange Beach Lady Makos - Photo by Brent Williams, Wolf Bay Media
By John Mullen April 30, 2026
Orange Beach, Ala. – (OBA) – The Orange Beach Lady Makos advanced to the second round of the Class 4A state playoffs with a 10-0 win on the road at New Brockton on Tuesday night. The No. 2-ranked Lady Makos scored early and often, with Gami Ausmuth scoring four goals en route to the blowout win. The home game highlight
Grand Lagoon Yacht Club - Stock Image
By R. Ken Cooper April 30, 2026
Perdido Key, Fla. — (OBA) — The Perdido Key Area Chamber of Commerce is kicking off a new event series for women in business. The Women Mean Business Committee created the LeadHer Lunch Series to connect, inspire, and empower professional women in the area. The series showcases local leaders making a real difference
Gulf Coast Businesses Are Saddling Up for Kentucky Derby Celebrations
By OBA Staff April 30, 2026
Orange Beach, Ala. — (OBA) — The Kentucky Derby is one of the United States' most celebrated sporting events, and Gulf Coast residents will have several ways to join the fun this year. Three venues in Orange Beach and Gulf Shores will host watch parties this weekend. Fans can expect live music, themed cocktails, costu
Gulf Shores City Hall
By OBA Staff April 29, 2026
Gulf Shores, Ala. — (OBA) — At their Monday night meeting, the Gulf Shores City Council approved a pre-zoning and annexation request for the Riviera property. The decision permits a new residential and commercial development. The property sits at the northwest corner of County Road 8 West and Highway 59. City official
Nesting season runs through late October
By R. Ken Cooper April 29, 2026
Orange Beach, Ala. — (OBA) — Sea turtle nesting season is set to begin along the northern Gulf Coast, including Alabama, Florida, and Mississippi. The annual event brings threatened sea turtles ashore to lay eggs. Officials say public awareness is key to protecting the endangered animal and urge beachgoers to follow s
Facility engineered to withstand 160 mph winds and store vessels up to 55 feet
By OBA Staff April 29, 2026
Gulf Shores, Ala. — (OBA) — With hurricane season approaching, boat owners along the Alabama Gulf Coast are being urged to be prepared. Legendary Marina & Yacht Club in Gulf Shores is offering storage options designed to protect vessels during a major storm. The marina is one of the only facilities on the Gulf Coast
Flora-Bama Lounge
By R. Peevy April 28, 2026
Orange Beach, Ala. — (OBA) — The iconic Flora-Bama has been nominated for USA Today's 10Best Readers' Choice Awards for Best Beach Bar. This selection, made by a panel of experts, puts the legendary spot in the national spotlight, with the ultimate winner determined by public votes.
54th Annual Art In The Park Returns To Downtown Foley
By OBA Staff April 28, 2026
Foley, Ala. — (OBA) — The Foley Art Center will host the 54th Annual Art in the Park in Heritage Park on Mother’s Day Weekend in downtown Foley. The event is held each year at the intersection of Highways 59 and 98. Planners say the festival will feature more than 80 artists. The event is free and open to the public.
Three Makos Teams Ready for Postseason Play This Week
By John Mullen April 28, 2026
Orange Beach, Ala. – (OBA) – It’ll be a busy week in post-season play for at least three Orange Beach Makos spring sports teams. Two teams – baseball and girls' soccer – will play state tournament games, with baseball at home and girls' soccer on the road. The Lady Makos softball powerhouse will be the host team for...
Residential Developments Proposed Near Hospital, Sportsplex, and Oyster Bay
By John Mullen April 28, 2026
Gulf Shores, Ala. – (OBA) – A short meeting agenda for the Gulf Shores Planning Commission is long on requests for 256 new residences in three subdivisions planned in the city. Expansion areas include one for townhomes across State Route 59 from the Baldwin Regional Medical Center’s freestanding emergency department.
Show More